The Gobblers Knob


The 3 Stages of Earle
September 12, 2007, 2:26 am
Filed under: Blog, Music, MySpace Bands, Old School, Random, Video, You Tube, blah blah blah, live gigs

steve-earle.jpgThis is Earle, perhaps he is entering a new stage with that beard…

One of our countries greatest writers, singers, and depending on who you ask, activists, is about to release a new album after a 3 year wait.  Steve Earle is back on Sept. 25.  I’ll spare you the trite, cliche ridden synopsis on what this new album represents or why he went in a more folksy, earthy direction, you’ll get plenty of that from magazines and blogs that think they are the only reviewer that’ll mention Earle’s politics, new marriage, move to NYC and busy non-music schedule.  What I’d like to share with you, my sweet and somewhat dirty reader, are what I call the “Three Stages of Earle.“  They are as follows:

  • Heartland Hillbilly Stage” - From the release of Guitar Town and Exit O, to the revelation of Copperhead Road, Earle went against the grain of the “anti-hillbilly” movement in Nashville of the mid-80’s.  His tales of life on the road, pistols, moonshine, dreams of “Someday” and “Hillbilly Highways” flew in the face of the pop-leaning, slickly arranged product that radio was playing at the time (sound familiar?).  “Guitar Town” didn’t have a chorus, “Hillybilly Highway” supposedly made country people look more backwards than they wanted to, and “Copperhead Road” was too rockin’, talked about pot, and also didn’t have that chorus hook that was usually mandatory for a song to see the light of the FM day.  Regardless of the trends going against him, Earle, along with Lyle Lovett and Dwight Yoakam headed a resurgence of artists that could succeed without conforming, as well as honoring their influences. Earle would soon fall victim to addiction and find himself in jail (enough has been said of that, hasn’t it?).  A couple of off-the-mark releases (Train a Comin’ anyone) would usher him into his next phase of brilliance.
  • “Bluegrass Rehab Rocker stage” - In what is easily Earle’s most prolific and creatively brilliant stage, he picks up where he left off (before jail) and defies convention and genre classification even further.  With the releases of I Feel Alright (’96), El Corazon (’97), the Bluegrass collabo. The Montain (’99), and ending the millenium with Transcendental Blues (2000), Earle reinforced his grip on his title as one of the world’s great singer/songwriters. Each of these albums contained a rainbow of tempos, themes, and styles.  Straight-ahead rock was prevelant in songs like “Hardcore Troubadour,” “Taneytown,” “Poison Lover,” and “Transcendental Blues”.  His typical melange of country meeting rock was evident in the tracks “You’re Still Standing There” (the awesome duet with frequent collaborator Lucinda Williams) and “Telephone Road”.  What set these albums apart was Earle going way back in his musical education and brushing up on his Bluegrass pickin’.  Earle’s days playing in a bluegrass band occurred even before his days of hanging with Townes Van Zandt and Guy Clark.  High-Lonesome cuts such as “I Still Carry You Around” and “Galway Girl” gave Earle a chance to do a little grinnin’ with his pickin’.  The marriage of the mandolin strings enveloping the nasaly tone of Earle was a bond that would beyond a random cut an album here and there.  In 1999 Earle teamed with Bluegrass legend Del McCoury to produce The Mountain.  On CD, the blending of talents seemed to work perfectly, however, reports indicate that the personalities of Earle and McCoury didn’t mesh as well.  Thankfully, the album produced some solid sounds and the track “Harlan Man”, where Earle declares “I’m a Union Man foreshadows the left-leaning ideologies that Earle would later promote and gain recognition for, giving him a second career as a liberal spokesman.
  • “Hardcore Protesting Troubadour Stage” - With the 2002 release of Jerusalem, Earle walks defiantly into the territory of talk-show subject instead of talk-show musical guest.  With the ballad “John Walker’s Blues,”, a tale through the eyes of the infamous “American Taliban,”, Earle was called names and cursed for sympathizing with someone considered evil in a post-9/11 climate.  The title track, “Jerusalem” was a classic country rocker in the vein of “Hardcore Troubadour,” complete with harmonica and a soaring chorus.  The songs subject matter, concerning history’s countless conflicts in the Middle East, was what made this yet another hot-button for the Bill O’ Limbaughs that attempted (unsuccessfully, in my opinion) to be “fair and balanced.”.  Earle, feeling the burden of helping abolish the death penalty, continued to stretch his piss-people-off-and-make-my-point legs with the release of The Revolution Starts Now, his anti-Bush, anti-Iraq War collection of stories (”Home to Houston” & “The Gringo’s Tale”), declarations of love for Condi Rice (”Condi Condi”), and declarations of hatred for other governement fixtures (”F the CC”), along with the plea for people to rise up (”The Revolution Starts Now”).  In earlier songs that shared a message of a political nature, Earle conveyed that message through the guise of telling a story, trying to show the other, voiceless side.  This album is Earle’s middle finger being held directly in front of the White House doors.  The upcoming release, “Washington Square,” kicks off with Earle returning more to the protest-through-stories-of-other-people in the form of “City of Immigrants.”  This is billed as a love song to Earle’s new hometown of NYC, and the past power of folk music to bring people and thoughts together for the betterment of society.  The track listing seems to contain titles that mirror past albums such as El Corozon and Transcendental Blues, yet we have been told to expect a folksier, more acoustic vibe as compared to those albums.

Many of you who consider yourselves “Earle Afficionados” may disagree with these stages and phases.  You could have a point if you take exception to me trying to categorize a body of work that has purposely avoided categorization.  If that’s your beef with this post, ok, you got me…..


8 Comments so far
Leave a comment

I saw Steve Earle in Chattanooga during the “Bluegrass Rehab Rocker Stage” at a small acoustic show with his son. He was great. But I believe that this stage overlapped tremendously with the “Hardcore Protesting Troubadour Stage”, because he was in a full fledged rant over every liberal issue on thetable at the time. A couple friends of mine (we are in relative states of conservatism) were there with me and we got in a discussion about whether we could continue to enjoy music by an artist that voiced polar opposite views as us. One of my friends vowed he was done with Earle, while I able to appreciate the music without getting offended by the message. Just wondering your thoughts on that.

Comment by Fitz September 12, 2007 @ 8:13 pm

I agree with you that the last two phases overlap somewhat, I mainly used the subject matter of the songs in each “stage” to show at least some differences as far as timeline goes. For example, in the “Bluegras Rehab Rocker Stage”, there were more love songs and stories focusing on various situations not having to do with politics, in the next phase, that changes considerably, as the focus shifts into politics, forsaking completely any traditional rockin’ love song on “Revolution Starts Now”. Also, I tend to be able to appreciate an artists product, regardless of their politics as well, whether it be Earle, Dave Matthews, Springsteen, Willie Nelson, or Neil Young. That being said, you better have the skins on the wall that these voices have if you are going to ramble on about your views and hope people tag along. Thanks so much for reading and commenting!

Comment by Kelly September 12, 2007 @ 8:24 pm

Great Web site, my first time here.

I must point out that you left out a pivotal stage in Earle’s career, maybe you could call it the “Strung-out Rocker” stage. You mentioned “Copperhead Road,” the song, but “Copperhead Road” the album (and consequently the single) were marketed exclusively to Rock stations. The follow-up, “The Hard Way” saw Earle press even harder on the Rock edge, but also hinted at his future activist songs with the brillant “Billy Austin.”

Sonically “Copperhead Road” was a sharp turn from “Exit O” while “Hard Way” continued what he started with CR. And that’s when he went to jail.

I, personally, would hesitate to call “Train a Comin’” off-the-mark. It was largely overlooked at the time of it’s release, but in retrospect it was a daring move for Earle, fresh from prison and coping with his drug addiction to enter the studio and strip it completely back to the bare bones. It is a complete 180 from “Hard Way” and helped put his feet back on the path that leads to “I Feel Alright.”

Comment by C. Eric Banister September 13, 2007 @ 3:03 pm

Thanks Eric! I tend to agree with you on most of your points. I lumped in “Copperhead” and “Exit O” more for the subject matter versus the sonics (you got a draw a line somehwhere I guess). I knew when I posted this I would likely not only have people see things a bit differently than I, but I would actually change my own mind a bit in the process. I think there could easily be 4 to 6 stages of Earle’s career, and you clearly pointed to where one could define a stage on top of what I defined originally. I also should’ve been more clear on my “off the mark” remark regarding “Train”, I actually love each album, and me commenting that it was “off the mark” is similar to saying A-Rod is having a bad year when he hits less than 50 homers in a season, due to the bar being so high. In this age of artists that quickly burn bright and then flame out even more quickly, it is amazing that Earle has fought back from the addiction that crippled him for so long, and has become more relevant and vital than ever, in my opinion.

Comment by Kelly September 13, 2007 @ 3:16 pm

I think you were spot on with your categories and it would be hard to put “Hard Way” in a spot simply because it is probably the most overlooked Earle album, made at the tail end of that part of his career when his drug addiction was full-blown. It is still one of my favorite Earle albums (if “Roadmaster” doesn’t make you press the gas a little more, I don’t know what will).

I think you are right, he has, and continues to become more relevant and vital than ever. I am looking forward to getting the deluxe edition of the CD for the DVD extras. And I have never seen him live with just an acoustic, so I am looking forward to the tour!

Comment by C. Eric Banister September 13, 2007 @ 3:42 pm

I have seen him, back in early ‘05 on the “Revolution…” tour. I was up front and center, as he ripped through an impressive cross-section of his entire catalog. The highlight for me was when he busted out the mandolin for “Galway Girl” , then seemlessly proceeded to the intro of “copperhead road” It was in Dallas, and he only made one anti-Bush remark, which I found surprising. I am hoping to get in to the kzps (dallas radio station) studio tommorrow to catch his radio interview as he will do a couple of acoustic songs (fingers crossed, big time).

Comment by Kelly September 13, 2007 @ 3:47 pm

The studio thing would very cool. I have seen him three times during the Transcendental Blues, Jerusalem and Revolution tours. Great shows!

Comment by C. Eric Banister September 13, 2007 @ 4:07 pm

[...] The 3 Stages of Earle [...]

Pingback by A softer, gentler road of copperheads…. « The Gobblers Knob September 15, 2007 @ 1:01 am



Leave a comment
Line and paragraph breaks automatic, e-mail address never displayed, HTML allowed: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>